Login

Cart

Your cart is empty

Mischief Collection

Our collection of pun-ny, mischievous, and even trollish decision makers, Dad Jokes, and puzzles.

Sort by

16 products

I Win / You Lose Coin Toss Decision Maker in nickel-silver - coin by Shire Post MintI Win / You Lose Coin Toss Decision Maker in nickel-silver - coin by Shire Post Mint
I Win/You Lose Decision Maker Sale price$15.06
Be Good/Stay Evil Decision MakerBe Good / Stay Evil Coin Toss Decision Maker by Shire Post Mint
Be Good/Stay Evil Decision Maker Sale price$22.57
Save $21.06Done Right, Done Quick - Decision Maker Coin in Solid CopperDone Right, Done Quick - Decision Maker Coin in Solid Copper
Done Right, Done Quick - Decision Maker Coin in Solid Copper Sale price$21.07 Regular price$42.13
Magic octagon brain teaser puzzle coin in solid copper set against a black leather background Magic octagon brain teaser puzzle coin in solid copper set against a black leather background
Magic Octagon Brain Teaser Coin in Solid Copper Sale price$25.59
Naughty or Nice Decision Maker - Krampus and Santa Copper Coin Stocking Stuffer Christmas GiftsNaughty or Nice Decision Maker - Krampus and Santa Copper Coin Stocking Stuffer Christmas Gifts
Naughty or Nice Decision Maker - Krampus and Santa Copper Coin Sale price$22.57
Labyrinth Firey Decision MakerLabyrinth Jim Henson Firey Decision Maker by Shire Post Mint
Labyrinth Firey Heads or Tails Decision Maker Brass Coin Sale price$37.63
Naughty or Nice Decision Maker - Krampus Black Iron CoinNaughty or Nice Decision Maker - Krampus Black Iron Coin
Naughty or Nice Decision Maker - Krampus Black Iron Coin Sale price$30.11
Optical Illusion Worry CoinOptical Illusion Worry Coin
Optical Illusion Worry Coin Sale price$30.11
"Counter-Fit" Fifty-Cent Piece: Fits Right on the Counter!"Counter-Fit" Fifty-Cent Piece: Fits Right on the Counter!
"Counter-Fit" Fifty-Cent Piece: Fits Right on the Counter! Sale price$7.51
Random Facts You Don't Really Need! (Copper, Brass & Bronze)Shire Post Mint Assorted Brass Copper and Bronze Metal Facts
Random Facts You Don't Really Need! (Copper, Brass & Bronze) Sale price$18.05
Brass coin depicting Forklift Certified cartoonish figure operating a forklift Brass coin depicting text, Don't Worry, the Bearer of this Medal is Forklift Certified'
Forklift Certified Coin in Brass Sale priceFrom $37.63
Sold outHands putting bronze optical illusion togetherShire Post Mint Bronze Crescent Puzzle
Crescent Optical Illusion Puzzle Sale price$45.14
Shadow Mephit Token - Rare Elements Foundry | Shire Post MintShadow Mephit Token - Rare Elements Foundry | Shire Post Mint
Shadow Mephit Token Sale price$22.57
Hand holding copper Exposure Coin, showing the crowned skullHand holding copper Exposure Coin, showing the crowned king
Exposure Coin® in Solid Copper Sale price$30.11
Random Facts You Don't Really Need! (Mokume-Gane)Shire Post Mint Mokume-Gane Metal Facts
Random Facts You Don't Really Need! (Mokume-Gane) Sale price$60.20
Random Facts You Don't Really Need (Silver)Shire Post Mint Silver Facts
Random Facts You Don't Really Need (Silver) Sale price$158.46