Login

Cart

Your cart is empty

40 Gifts for Them under $40

Howdy Buckaroo! Are you looking for a gift for them, too? If you're shopping for your partner in crime, your best pal, the crow you've recently befriended, or the cryptid that may reside in your backyard, you have found the right place! A gathering of unique gifts for them that are sure to inspire you and your chosen companion to even greater shenanigans! 

Sort by

46 products

axolotl gills decision maker copper xolotl valley of mexico by shire post mintaxolotl copper coin packaging by shire post mint
Axolotl Decision Maker Coin in Solid Copper Sale price$22.17
Black Goat of Qohor CoinBlack Goat of Qohor Coin
Black Goat of Qohor Coin Sale price$25.14
Black Goat of Qohor NecklaceBlack Goat of Qohor Necklace
Black Goat of Qohor Necklace Sale price$39.94
Blue and Purple Moon Coin - 1" Anodized Niobium blurple gift outrunBlue and Purple Moon Coin - 1" Anodized Niobium blurple gift outrun
Blue and Purple Moon Coin - 1 in / 26 mm Anodized Niobium Sale price$59.14
Blue Roswell Coin - Alien ArtifactBlue Roswell Coin - Alien Artifact
Blue Roswell Coin - Alien Artifact Sale price$32.53
Burnt Supreme Pizza Coin with Tiny Pizza Box | Shire Post Mint | Funny GiftsBurnt Supreme Pizza Coin with Tiny Pizza Box | Shire Post Mint | Funny Gifts
Burnt Supreme Pizza Coin with Tiny Pizza Box Sale price$29.58
Pile of Shire Post Mint Copper Hand Poured Worry Stone Fidget PucksShire Post Mint Copper Hand Poured Worry Stone Fidget Puck
Copper Hand Poured Worry Stone Fidget Puck Sale price$51.75
Brass Coin with text, 'Follow that Yellow Road' depicting Baum's famous yellow brick road leading up to the Emerald City displayed against a book pageBrass coin with text, 'There Is No Place Like Home' depicting a sleeping dog on a sunny porch displayed on a book page
Dorothy's Decision Maker Coin in Brass Sale price$29.58
Fine silver coin with text, 'Follow that Yellow Road' depicting the Emerald City and Baum's famous yellow brick road, displayed on a book page next to a penny-size bronze token of a fluffy tailFine silver coin with text, 'There is No Place Like Home' depicting a sleeping dog on a sunny porch, displayed on a book page next to a bronze penny-size token of Toto from the Wonderful Wizard of Oz
Dorothy's Decision Maker Coin in Silver Sale price$155.68
Hand holding earthenware green worry finchFidget Finches Ceramic Bird Worry Stone
Fidget Finches Ceramic Bird Worry Stone Sale price$17.73
Fire Dragon and Ice Hydra Copper TokenFire Dragon and Ice Hydra Copper Token
Fire Dragon and Ice Hydra Copper Token Sale price$29.58
Copper Fungible Token by Shire Post MintCopper Fungible Token by Shire Post Mint
Fungible Token Decision Maker Coin in Solid Copper Sale price$22.17
Haptic Pair of Sliding Pickle Chips Worry Coins - Raw CopperHaptic Pair of Sliding Pickle Chips Worry Coins - Raw Copper
Haptic Pair of Sliding Pickle Chips Worry Coins - Raw Copper Sale price$66.54
King Arthur Coin - Silver Siliqua of Arthur PendragonKing Arthur Coin - Silver Siliqua of Arthur Pendragon
King Arthur Coin - Silver Siliqua of Arthur Pendragon Sale price$38.44
Labyrinth Firey Decision MakerLabyrinth Jim Henson Firey Decision Maker by Shire Post Mint
Labyrinth Firey Heads or Tails Decision Maker Brass Coin Sale price$36.97
Labyrinth | Goblin King and Goblin City Copper CoinLabyrinth | Goblin King and Goblin City Copper Coin
Labyrinth | Goblin King and Goblin City Copper Coin Sale price$36.97
Lucky Duck Coin in BrassLucky Duck Coin in Brass
Lucky Duck Coin in Brass Sale price$17.73
Lucky Rainbow Penny Necklace or Keychain, NiobiumLucky Rainbow Penny Necklace or Keychain, Niobium
Lucky Rainbow Penny Necklace or Keychain, Niobium Sale priceFrom $39.94
Mars red planet martian olympus mons valles marineris worry coin | Shire Post MintMars red planet martian olympus mons valles marineris space necklace pendant | Shire Post Mint
Mars Coin - Copper Sale price$29.58
Morel and Amanita Mushrooms of Earth Charm or Necklace in Solid CopperMorel and Amanita Mushrooms of Earth Charm or Necklace in Solid Copper
Morel and Amanita Mushrooms of Earth Charm or Necklace in Solid Copper Sale priceFrom $36.97
Morel mushroom mycology fungus bloom earthworms mycelium by Shire Post MintAmanita mushroom mycology fungus fruit earthworms mycelium by Shire Post Mint
Morel and Amanita Mushrooms of Earth Coin in Solid Copper Sale price$29.58
Naughty or Nice Decision Maker - Krampus and Santa Copper Coin Stocking Stuffer Christmas GiftsNaughty or Nice Decision Maker - Krampus and Santa Copper Coin Stocking Stuffer Christmas Gifts
Naughty or Nice Decision Maker - Krampus and Santa Copper Coin Sale price$22.17
Night's Watch Copper TokenNight's Watch Copper Token
Night's Watch Copper Token Sale price$29.58
Nosferatu Count Orlok Brass CoinNosferatu Count Orlok Brass Coin
Nosferatu Count Orlok Brass Coin Sale price$17.73
One More Chapter / Go to Bed Copper Decision Maker CoinOne More Chapter / Go to Bed Copper Decision Maker Coin
One More Chapter / Go to Bed Copper Decision Maker Coin Sale price$22.17
Pearl Cream Upcycled Bowling Ball Worry Stone | Shire Post Mint GiftsPearl Cream Upcycled Bowling Ball Worry Stone | Shire Post Mint Gifts
Pearl Cream Upcycled Bowling Ball Worry Stone Sale price$22.17
Pet the Cat / Flip Again Copper Decision Maker CoinPet the Cat / Flip Again Copper Decision Maker Coin
Pet the Cat / Flip Again Copper Decision Maker Coin Sale price$22.17
Pirate Roberts Coin in Solid CopperPirate Roberts Coin in Solid Copper
Pirate Roberts Coin in Solid Copper Sale price$17.73
Rainbow Moon Coin - 1 in / 26 mm Multicolored Anodized NiobiumRainbow Moon Coin - 1 in / 26 mm Multicolored Anodized Niobium
Rainbow Moon Coin - 1 in / 26 mm Multicolored Anodized Niobium Sale price$59.14
Raven Penny of New DaleRaven Penny of New Dale
Raven Penny of New Dale Sale price$14.79
Rhaenyra Targaryen ASOIAF GOT Shire Post Mint Game of ThronesRhaenyra Targaryen ASOIAF GOT Shire Post Mint
Rhaenyra Targaryen Golden Dragon Coin Sale price$22.17
Transgender Flag Pride Tag Anodized Titanium Charm | Shire Post MintTransgender Flag Pride Tag Anodized Titanium Charm | Shire Post Mint
Transgender Pride Flag Tag in Anodized Titanium Sale priceFrom $44.35
Two-Year Calendar Coin (2026-2027)Two-Year Calendar Coin (2026-2027)
Two-Year Calendar Coin (2026-2027) Sale priceFrom $29.58
Zelda Gray Mix Upcycled Bowling Ball Worry StoneZelda Gray Mix Upcycled Bowling Ball Worry Stone
Zelda Gray Mix Upcycled Bowling Ball Worry Stone Sale price$22.17
Zodiac Aquarius Moon Silver CoinZodiac Aquarius Moon Silver Coin
Zodiac Aquarius Moon Silver Coin Sale price$50.29
Zodiac Aries Moon Silver CoinZodiac Aries Moon Silver Coin
Zodiac Aries Moon Silver Coin Sale price$50.29
Zodiac Cancer Moon Silver CoinZodiac Cancer Moon Silver Coin
Zodiac Cancer Moon Silver Coin Sale price$50.29
Zodiac Capricorn Moon Silver CoinZodiac Capricorn Moon Silver Coin
Zodiac Capricorn Moon Silver Coin Sale price$50.29
Zodiac Gemini Moon Silver CoinZodiac Gemini Moon Silver Coin
Zodiac Gemini Moon Silver Coin Sale price$50.29
Zodiac Leo Moon Silver CoinZodiac Leo Moon Silver Coin
Zodiac Leo Moon Silver Coin Sale price$50.29
Zodiac Libra Moon Silver CoinZodiac Libra Moon Silver Coin
Zodiac Libra Moon Silver Coin Sale price$50.29
Sold outZodiac Pisces Moon Silver CoinZodiac Pisces Moon Silver Coin
Zodiac Pisces Moon Silver Coin Sale price$50.29
Zodiac Sagittarius Moon Silver CoinZodiac Sagittarius Moon Silver Coin
Zodiac Sagittarius Moon Silver Coin Sale price$50.29
Zodiac Scorpio Moon Silver CoinZodiac Scorpio Moon Silver Coin
Zodiac Scorpio Moon Silver Coin Sale price$50.29
Zodiac Taurus Moon Silver CoinZodiac Taurus Moon Silver Coin
Zodiac Taurus Moon Silver Coin Sale price$50.29
Zodiac Virgo Moon Silver CoinZodiac Virgo Moon Silver Coin
Zodiac Virgo Moon Silver Coin Sale price$50.29